Thank you to Random House Publishing Group for providing me with an advance copy of Matthew Klam’s novel, Who is Rich?, in exchange for an honest review.
PLOT – Rich Fischer is a graphic novelist who achieved acclaim early in his career. His success was limited and now, middle-aged, he is trying to get his art career back on track. Rich teaches at a summer retreat, where he looks forward to reconnecting with Amy, a painter with whom he is having an affair. Both Amy and Rich are married with young children and both are unhappy in their relationships. They fantasize about running away from their spouses, but neither is willing to take action. Amy is married to an extremely wealthy businessman and although she is unhappy, she does not want for anything else. Rich is not wealthy, he has the trappings of a middle-class life that he is struggling to maintain paycheck-to-paycheck. He envies Amy’s financial freedom and the success of his peers. What does it mean to be rich? How does focusing on what you lack make you feel poorer?
LIKE– I liked the concept of Who is Rich?. The themes of envy are very relatable and Rich is a relatable character. I’m not sure that I personally connected to him, but I have people in my life who are similar to Rich. Specifically, I see Rich’s flaws and hang-ups in a few people that I know. I liked the setting of an art retreat, with a large cast of colorful secondary characters. Klam has created a vibrant world and he has fabulous descriptions.
Although I disagree that this story was a comedy, Klam has written some witty phrases and observations that made me crack a smile. There were many times that I paused to admire his writing or even to read aloud a paragraph to feel the pacing.
I liked that Klam used illustrations in his novel. It was a great fit for his protagonist’s profession and the pictures were a fun inclusion.
The title is wonderful play on both the theme and the protagonist’s name.
DISLIKE- On a whole, I didn’t connect with the story. It was sluggish and a chore to read. I actually read several books in-between, rather than reading Who is Rich? straight through. If this had not been a review copy, I likely would not have finished reading it. The story does pick up pace in the last 10% of the book, when Rich has a major moral dilemma regarding a pair of earrings. I wish the stakes/drama had been more intense earlier in the story.
RECOMMEND– No. Who is Rich? was not my cup of tea. That said, I liked Klam’s writing enough that I plan to check-out his previously published short story collection, Sam The Cat. I have a feeling that Klam might really shine in a shorter format.